Comparison table

Six materials side by side under the same criteria. The order is alphabetical, not a ranking. Scores are the author's judgment, always shown with the strength of the evidence and "Not scored". Hover over a score to see the reason.

Basic information (US list prices. Checked: 2026-11-21)
Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain)Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF)
Official pageAlfred official
Content not confirmed (access restricted)
Kjos (publisher) site
Product page not confirmed
IMSLP (public score library)
Display confirmed
Faber official store
Display confirmed
Hal Leonard official
Display confirmed
SightPiano official (the developer's site)
Display confirmed
Pages160 (some stores say 144; Amazon shows 999, which is unreliable; Open Library says 160/162) Retail160 Retail77–93 (varies by scanned edition) Official184 Official96 Official172 pages in the Japanese edition (A4). The English edition is 171 pages, 3.7 MB Original
Price (USD)$19.99 Secondary$19.99 SecondaryFree ($0) Official$19.99 Official$19.99 OfficialFree ($0) Official
Year of publicationCD edition: July 1994 (Open Library only). DVD edition: June 1, 2011 (Amazon.com) CatalogJanuary 1, 1999 (Amazon.com). The library catalog also says 1999 Retail1850, Mainz: Schott Official2002, 2016 (the publication-date field in the product information) OfficialFebruary 28, 2005 (Amazon.com; the ISBN's registration date). The older edition with a CD is August 24, 2006 RetailNovember 2026, first edition (PDF created 2026-11-18) Original
ISBNDiffers by edition. 9780882849317 (with CD), 9780739082423 (with DVD). The official Wire-O edition is item number 00-5753; the Book & CD edition is 00-5756 Retail9780849773006 (Book & Online Access), 9780849773020 (book only) RetailNo data recorded9781616773021 Official9780634066269 (current edition with online audio). The older edition with a CD, 9781423417606, is a separate product OfficialNo data recorded
Audio and video (or how to get it)Enter the access code on Alfred's media site. Creating a login with an email address is required. Play and download in My Library Official16-digit code. "Download the IPS software" from kjos.com/ips RetailNo explanations, audio, or video. One performance recording on IMSLP (No. 62, CC BY-SA 4.0) OfficialOnline audio and video (over 2 hours) OfficialOver 150 orchestral accompaniments. PLAYBACK+ offers speed change (pitch unchanged), looping, transposition, and left/right balance OfficialSelf-contained in one book. Has sections for teachers and parents. The PDF has no audio or video. The app (MIDI keyboard required) gives judging Original

Scores by criterion

"Not scored" means there was not enough material to judge (it is not a low rating).

Scores by criterion (the author's judgment; "Evidence" is the strength of the evidence)
Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain)Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF)
C1 A quick "this is music" experience3Evidence: LowNot scored2Evidence: Low3Evidence: Low4Evidence: Medium3Evidence: Medium
C2 Pieces you like and know4Evidence: Medium3Evidence: Low1Evidence: Medium3Evidence: Medium4Evidence: Medium2Evidence: High
C3 Suitable pace3Evidence: Medium3Evidence: Low2Evidence: Medium4Evidence: Medium3Evidence: Medium4Evidence: Low
C4 Gradual, explicit introduction of note reading3Evidence: MediumNot scoredNot scored4Evidence: Medium4Evidence: Medium5Evidence: Medium
C5 Support for how to practice (within the book)3Evidence: Medium3Evidence: LowNot scored3Evidence: MediumNot scored5Evidence: High
C6 Support for self-study (audio, video, explanations)2Evidence: Medium3Evidence: Low1Evidence: High4Evidence: Medium4Evidence: Medium3Evidence: Medium
C7 Consideration for limited time3Evidence: LowNot scored3Evidence: Low3Evidence: Low4Evidence: Low4Evidence: Low
C8 Practical skills (chords, theory, ear, improvisation, transposition)4Evidence: Medium3Evidence: Low1Evidence: Medium4Evidence: Medium5Evidence: Medium3Evidence: High
C9 Body and technique (posture, hand shape, relaxation)5Evidence: HighNot scored1Evidence: Low3Evidence: Low3Evidence: Low5Evidence: High
C10 Adult-oriented look and tone3Evidence: MediumNot scored1Evidence: Medium5Evidence: High3Evidence: Medium4Evidence: High
C11 Purchase cost2Evidence: Low3Evidence: Low5Evidence: High3Evidence: High2Evidence: High5Evidence: Medium
C12 Track record4Evidence: Low3Evidence: Medium5Evidence: Medium5Evidence: Medium5Evidence: Medium1Evidence: High
Average
C1–C10 + C12. Scored items only
3.4 (11 items)3.0 (6 items)
Too many items not scored; not usable for comparison
1.9 (9 items)3.7 (11 items)3.9 (10 items)3.5 (11 items)

The average is a reference value calculated only from the items that could be scored; it is not a ranking. Purchase cost (C11) is not included. Other averages, such as one without the track record (C12), are in Criteria & averages. If the difference is within 0.5, you cannot say there is a difference.

Details by criterion

C1 A quick "this is music" experience

Pages before the first piece; what the first piece is

C2 Pieces you like and know

Kinds of pieces, and the share of well-known ones

C3 Suitable pace

How quickly new elements arrive; amount of review

C4 Gradual, explicit introduction of note reading

Starting position, the page where the staff appears, new notes per page

C5 Support for how to practice (within the book)

Practice tips, unit goals, review, self-checks

C6 Support for self-study (audio, video, explanations)

Accompaniment audio, video, speed control, amount of explanation

C7 Consideration for limited time

Length of a unit; how it is chunked

C8 Practical skills (chords, theory, ear, improvisation, transposition)

Whether the relevant pages exist

C9 Body and technique (posture, hand shape, relaxation)

Instruction on posture and hand shape; technique exercises

C10 Adult-oriented look and tone

Layout, type size, tone

C11 Purchase cost (Purchase cost. Not included in the main average)

Spending needed to work through Book 1 using the audio too (US list price)

C12 Track record

Years since first publication; edition and revision history; number of independent user voices

Verification levels