Notes from a beginner

A beginner looked into
the first piano book to buy.

An adult piano beginner shares what was found while choosing learning materials, for others in the same position. I am neither a teacher nor an expert. Let's get better together.

Three promises

  1. 1

    Every material is written up under the same criteria

    The same 12 criteria and the same format. The order is alphabetical, not a ranking.

  2. 2

    Facts and judgments are separated, and "we don't know" is not hidden

    Every item carries a verification level and a check date. What could not be confirmed is marked "Unconfirmed" (this does not mean "absent").

  3. 3

    Mistakes are fixed and recorded

    Corrections are recorded in the change log. Many were made even during the research.

The six materials compared

In alphabetical order. Not a ranking.

Materials in Japanese were not covered this time.

How to read this site

  1. Look at the six materials side by side in the comparison table.
  2. On the page of a material you are interested in, read the evidence, the sources, and what is unconfirmed.
  3. In Criteria & averages, check what the scores mean and their limits. Scores are the author's judgment, not a ranking.