- 6Materials compared
- 124Facts recorded (each with a check date)
- 34Sources
- 12Items marked "could not be confirmed"
- 17Published corrections
Three promises
- 1
Every material is written up under the same criteria
The same 12 criteria and the same format. The order is alphabetical, not a ranking.
- 2
Facts and judgments are separated, and "we don't know" is not hidden
Every item carries a verification level and a check date. What could not be confirmed is marked "Unconfirmed" (this does not mean "absent").
- 3
Mistakes are fixed and recorded
Corrections are recorded in the change log. Many were made even during the research.
The six materials compared
In alphabetical order. Not a ranking.
- Commercial method book
Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1
Read the table of contents and part of the text in an Internet Archive scan (an edition of unconfirmed year).
- Commercial method book
Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1
No material was available to check the contents of the book; the evidence is only retail sites and personal reviews.
- Public-domain book of studies
Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain)
Mainly IMSLP bibliographic information and reviews in Japanese and English.
- Commercial method book
Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1
Mainly the official pages and teacher reviews.
- Commercial method book
Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1
Mainly the official page and teacher reviews (3).
- Free PDF coursebook
SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF)
Read the whole Japanese-edition PDF (172 pages).
Materials in Japanese were not covered this time.
How to read this site
- Look at the six materials side by side in the comparison table.
- On the page of a material you are interested in, read the evidence, the sources, and what is unconfirmed.
- In Criteria & averages, check what the scores mean and their limits. Scores are the author's judgment, not a ranking.