Comparison table
Six materials side by side under the same criteria. The order is alphabetical, not a ranking. Scores are the author's judgment, always shown with the strength of the evidence and "Not scored". Hover over a score to see the reason.
| Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 | Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 | Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) | Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 | Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 | SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Official page | Alfred official Content not confirmed (access restricted) | Kjos (publisher) site Product page not confirmed | IMSLP (public score library) Display confirmed | Faber official store Display confirmed | Hal Leonard official Display confirmed | SightPiano official (the developer's site) Display confirmed |
| Pages | 160 (some stores say 144; Amazon shows 999, which is unreliable; Open Library says 160/162) Retail | 160 Retail | 77–93 (varies by scanned edition) Official | 184 Official | 96 Official | 172 pages in the Japanese edition (A4). The English edition is 171 pages, 3.7 MB Original |
| Price (USD) | $19.99 Secondary | $19.99 Secondary | Free ($0) Official | $19.99 Official | $19.99 Official | Free ($0) Official |
| Year of publication | CD edition: July 1994 (Open Library only). DVD edition: June 1, 2011 (Amazon.com) Catalog | January 1, 1999 (Amazon.com). The library catalog also says 1999 Retail | 1850, Mainz: Schott Official | 2002, 2016 (the publication-date field in the product information) Official | February 28, 2005 (Amazon.com; the ISBN's registration date). The older edition with a CD is August 24, 2006 Retail | November 2026, first edition (PDF created 2026-11-18) Original |
| ISBN | Differs by edition. 9780882849317 (with CD), 9780739082423 (with DVD). The official Wire-O edition is item number 00-5753; the Book & CD edition is 00-5756 Retail | 9780849773006 (Book & Online Access), 9780849773020 (book only) Retail | No data recorded | 9781616773021 Official | 9780634066269 (current edition with online audio). The older edition with a CD, 9781423417606, is a separate product Official | No data recorded |
| Audio and video (or how to get it) | Enter the access code on Alfred's media site. Creating a login with an email address is required. Play and download in My Library Official | 16-digit code. "Download the IPS software" from kjos.com/ips Retail | No explanations, audio, or video. One performance recording on IMSLP (No. 62, CC BY-SA 4.0) Official | Online audio and video (over 2 hours) Official | Over 150 orchestral accompaniments. PLAYBACK+ offers speed change (pitch unchanged), looping, transposition, and left/right balance Official | Self-contained in one book. Has sections for teachers and parents. The PDF has no audio or video. The app (MIDI keyboard required) gives judging Original |
Scores by criterion
"Not scored" means there was not enough material to judge (it is not a low rating).
| Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 | Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 | Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) | Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 | Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 | SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 A quick "this is music" experience | 3Evidence: Low | Not scored | 2Evidence: Low | 3Evidence: Low | 4Evidence: Medium | 3Evidence: Medium |
| C2 Pieces you like and know | 4Evidence: Medium | 3Evidence: Low | 1Evidence: Medium | 3Evidence: Medium | 4Evidence: Medium | 2Evidence: High |
| C3 Suitable pace | 3Evidence: Medium | 3Evidence: Low | 2Evidence: Medium | 4Evidence: Medium | 3Evidence: Medium | 4Evidence: Low |
| C4 Gradual, explicit introduction of note reading | 3Evidence: Medium | Not scored | Not scored | 4Evidence: Medium | 4Evidence: Medium | 5Evidence: Medium |
| C5 Support for how to practice (within the book) | 3Evidence: Medium | 3Evidence: Low | Not scored | 3Evidence: Medium | Not scored | 5Evidence: High |
| C6 Support for self-study (audio, video, explanations) | 2Evidence: Medium | 3Evidence: Low | 1Evidence: High | 4Evidence: Medium | 4Evidence: Medium | 3Evidence: Medium |
| C7 Consideration for limited time | 3Evidence: Low | Not scored | 3Evidence: Low | 3Evidence: Low | 4Evidence: Low | 4Evidence: Low |
| C8 Practical skills (chords, theory, ear, improvisation, transposition) | 4Evidence: Medium | 3Evidence: Low | 1Evidence: Medium | 4Evidence: Medium | 5Evidence: Medium | 3Evidence: High |
| C9 Body and technique (posture, hand shape, relaxation) | 5Evidence: High | Not scored | 1Evidence: Low | 3Evidence: Low | 3Evidence: Low | 5Evidence: High |
| C10 Adult-oriented look and tone | 3Evidence: Medium | Not scored | 1Evidence: Medium | 5Evidence: High | 3Evidence: Medium | 4Evidence: High |
| C11 Purchase cost | 2Evidence: Low | 3Evidence: Low | 5Evidence: High | 3Evidence: High | 2Evidence: High | 5Evidence: Medium |
| C12 Track record | 4Evidence: Low | 3Evidence: Medium | 5Evidence: Medium | 5Evidence: Medium | 5Evidence: Medium | 1Evidence: High |
| Average C1–C10 + C12. Scored items only | 3.4 (11 items) | 3.0 (6 items) Too many items not scored; not usable for comparison | 1.9 (9 items) | 3.7 (11 items) | 3.9 (10 items) | 3.5 (11 items) |
The average is a reference value calculated only from the items that could be scored; it is not a ranking. Purchase cost (C11) is not included. Other averages, such as one without the track record (C12), are in Criteria & averages. If the difference is within 0.5, you cannot say there is a difference.
Details by criterion
C1 A quick "this is music" experience
Pages before the first piece; what the first piece is
- Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 3Evidence: Low
After warm-ups, sitting posture, and the keyboard: right-hand C position (p.12), left hand (p.16) Original
An edition of unconfirmed year - Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 Not scored
No material available to confirm Unconfirmed - Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) 2Evidence: Low
Studies only. No titles, accompaniment, or audio. Details such as the range and content of the first piece are unconfirmed Official
"Studies only" is IMSLP's description. The score itself was not read - Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 3Evidence: Low
A short stretch of black keys only, then white keys Teacher - Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 4Evidence: Medium
Starts with black keys. Improvising on black keys with accompaniment, using "floating note shapes" and finger numbers Teacher - SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) 3Evidence: Medium
In step 1, the right middle finger plays only E, four beats each (1-1). It starts with the procedure of sitting down and finding E (p.6) Original
C2 Pieces you like and know
Kinds of pieces, and the share of well-known ones
- Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 4Evidence: Medium
Children's songs and folk songs, blues, popular standards (Over the Rainbow, At Last, Singin' in the Rain, etc.). About 70 pieces confirmed from the table of contents Original - Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 3Evidence: Low
Classical themes, folk songs, spirituals, ragtime, blues, boogie, jazz, originals. Also said: "few blues, jazz, or modern pieces until the second half" and "classical-centered". "Beautiful arrangements" and "ordinary" coexist Teacher
Includes JW Pepper's description (URL not recorded) - Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) 1Evidence: Medium
No titles, only numbers. "The pieces are monotonous" (grade A) Official - Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 3Evidence: Medium
Mostly folk songs and classical themes, with a little pop and jazz. Official examples: Catch a Falling Star, The Entertainer, Greensleeves, Happy Birthday, Eine Kleine Nachtmusik Official
"Mostly folk or classical" comes from a teacher review (The Tattooed Piano Teacher) - Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 4Evidence: Medium
Classical, folk, pop, jazz, blues (Vivaldi's "Spring", Scarborough Fair, etc.) Teacher
Grade A (six sources agree). Only one confirmation from an actual user - SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) 2Evidence: High
Of 130 pieces, 23 are simplified traditional or classical pieces (Twinkle Twinkle Little Star, Ode to Joy, Amazing Grace, Für Elise, etc.). The other 107 are originals. Pop, jazz, and blues cannot be confirmed from the titles Original
C3 Suitable pace
How quickly new elements arrive; amount of review
- Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 3Evidence: Medium
"A little faster than other Alfred books" (teacher). The last 10–15 pages are hard (user) Teacher
Grade B. The source URL was not recorded - Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 3Evidence: Low
Opinions split: "fast" (Katarina) / "gradual" (publisher-related) / 8–12 months (Richard) Teacher - Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) 2Evidence: Medium
Extremely slow. Little changes from piece to piece Inference
The actual structure is unconfirmed - Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 4Evidence: Medium
Faster than a typical method book but encouraging for adults / may be fast for a complete beginner. Takes 4–8 months (experience of a teacher giving weekly lessons) Teacher - Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 3Evidence: Medium
Some feel the opening is slow. Book 1 stops at an easier point than other methods Teacher - SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) 4Evidence: Low
One new thing per step. New things reappear many times in later pieces. "Move on after playing it three times in a row without stopping." No stated time to complete Original
C4 Gradual, explicit introduction of note reading
Starting position, the page where the staff appears, new notes per page
- Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 3Evidence: Medium
Middle C approach. Right-hand C position p.12, left hand p.16, grand staff and both hands p.20 (of 160 pages) Original - Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 Not scored
No material available to confirm Unconfirmed - Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) Not scored
Starts from the basics of the staff (details unconfirmed) Unconfirmed
The IMSLP scans could not be read - Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 4Evidence: Medium
Rotates hand positions: Middle C, neighboring notes, five-finger scales. Fast introduction of the grand staff on p.28, treble range p.82, bass range p.96 (of 184 pages). A new note about every page Teacher
The publisher describes a "gradual note-reading plan" (Faber official) - Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 4Evidence: Medium
Introduces low F and high G before Middle C. Sharps, flats, and naturals in Unit 3. The right hand stays in a five-note position through Unit 4 Teacher - SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) 5Evidence: Medium
From a single right-hand note, E. D in step 2, C in step 4. Middle C, bass clef, and left hand in step 6 (p.12); both hands in step 12 (p.20). Note names use solfège (do-re-mi) Original
C5 Support for how to practice (within the book)
Practice tips, unit goals, review, self-checks
- Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 3Evidence: Medium
"Take care of your hands", isometric exercises (p.10), hand massage (p.11), four reasons for playing with curved fingers (p.11). No instructions on how to practice were confirmed Original - Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 3Evidence: Low
A quiz, challenge piece, and technique check every few pages (one personal review) Teacher - Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) Not scored
No instructions in the text could be confirmed (it is not asserted that there are none) Unconfirmed - Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 3Evidence: Medium
New concept plus review in each unit (official). A 3-minute technique and one theory page per unit (teacher) Official - Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 Not scored
No review tests or self-checks were found Unconfirmed
"Not confirmed" does not mean "absent" - SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) 5Evidence: High
Practice steps are stated in the text (count aloud / play slowly without stopping / move on after three times / a little every day / pick out only the trouble spots / go back to earlier pieces) Original
C6 Support for self-study (audio, video, explanations)
Accompaniment audio, video, speed control, amount of explanation
- Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 2Evidence: Medium
The publisher intends use with a teacher (quoted on a teacher's site). Recordings come with some editions Teacher
The source URL was not recorded - Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 3Evidence: Low
The publisher does not say whether it is for self-study or use with a teacher. Comes with an Interactive Practice Studio (IPS) Retail - Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) 1Evidence: High
No explanations, audio, or video. One performance recording on IMSLP (No. 62, CC BY-SA 4.0) Official - Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 4Evidence: Medium
Online audio and video (over 2 hours) Official
Not confirmed whether every song has audio and video - Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 4Evidence: Medium
Officially: "independent learners without a teacher should start with Book 1". A teacher review: "do the theory pages together in class" Official - Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 4Evidence: Medium
Over 150 orchestral accompaniments. PLAYBACK+ offers speed change (pitch unchanged), looping, transposition, and left/right balance Official - Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 4Evidence: Medium
Officially "with a teacher or on your own". The text often says "your teacher" (teacher review) Official - SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) 3Evidence: Medium
Self-contained in one book. Has sections for teachers and parents. The PDF has no audio or video. The app (MIDI keyboard required) gives judging Original
C7 Consideration for limited time
Length of a unit; how it is chunked
- Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 3Evidence: Low
About 160 pages; suited to working through from start to finish Inference - Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 Not scored
No material on length or structure Unconfirmed - Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) 3Evidence: Low
The pieces are short, and you can work on one at a time Inference - Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 3Evidence: Low
Each unit combines a concept, review, and a 3-minute technique Official
Includes inference from length and structure - Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 4Evidence: Low
96 pages. With over 150 accompaniments you can practice at your own pace Official
Includes inference - SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) 4Evidence: Low
84 small steps. Recommends short daily practice. No stated time per step Original
C8 Practical skills (chords, theory, ear, improvisation, transposition)
Whether the relevant pages exist
- Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 4Evidence: Medium
C major chords p.32. Sharps around p.55, flats around p.97, G major around p.112 (later pages are approximate). Chord-centered Original
Later page numbers are approximate, filled in from a summary - Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 3Evidence: Low
Theory, technique, and sight-reading in one book. Ear training, improvisation, and transposition are not mentioned Teacher - Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) 1Evidence: Medium
No description of chords or theory Inference - Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 4Evidence: Medium
Theory pages, sight-reading, ear training, lead sheets, left-hand chord patterns. Improvisation and transposition not confirmed Official - Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 5Evidence: Medium
Improvisation from the start. Transposition early on, chords early in Book 1, and pedal is introduced Teacher - SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) 3Evidence: High
Theory is explained in each step. C major triad (p.71), I–IV–V (p.129), scale (p.137). Chord symbols, improvisation, transposition, and pedal are not covered Original
C9 Body and technique (posture, hand shape, relaxation)
Instruction on posture and hand shape; technique exercises
- Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 5Evidence: High
How to sit (p.6), hand shape, warm-ups, hand massage Original - Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 Not scored
No relevant description could be confirmed Unconfirmed - Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) 1Evidence: Low
A user's specific remark that explanations of pedal and positions are missing. Unconfirmed in the original User
An article on note (a Japanese blog platform). The source URL was not recorded. A search summary of Piano World says much the same - Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 3Evidence: Low
3-minute techniques for finger independence and relaxed wrists (official). Posture and hand shape not confirmed Official - Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 3Evidence: Low
Slurs, staccato, accents, hand-to-hand legato. Posture not confirmed Teacher - SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) 5Evidence: High
Step 1 explains sitting posture, hand shape, and finger numbers with diagrams. 14 instructions on wrist use. Thumb-under and octave leaps. No explanation of pedal Original
C10 Adult-oriented look and tone
Layout, type size, tone
- Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 3Evidence: Medium
"Plain" and "little context is explained" (the author says they have not used the book) Teacher
An article on PianoAfter40. The source URL was not recorded - Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 Not scored
No material on layout or tone ("old-fashioned" and "ordinary" are judgments of the music) Unconfirmed - Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) 1Evidence: Medium
Made for children (original title and dedication) Official - Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 5Evidence: High
No cute characters; an adult look (five sources agree) Teacher - Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 3Evidence: Medium
Opinions split: "no pictures aimed at children" and "professional" versus "looks aimed at children at the start with its large type" Teacher - SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) 4Evidence: High
No illustrations or characters. A calm explanatory tone in the polite "desu/masu" style. Kanji 27.2%, hiragana 57.4%, katakana 15.3%. The word "adult" appears 0 times. Not limited by age, with sections for teachers and parents Original
Character ratios are measured from the text. Note size was not measured
C11 Purchase cost (Purchase cost. Not included in the main average)
Spending needed to work through Book 1 using the audio too (US list price)
- Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 2Evidence: Low
$19.99 Secondary
Wire-O edition (00-5753). Initially judged to be the official page's price, but the source URL was not kept and it could not be re-verified (the official Book 1 page could not be read because of access restrictions). Treated as secondary information until re-verified. Whether this edition includes audio is unconfirmed. Separately sold digital audio at $11.99 is unconfirmed. The Book & CD edition is $26.48 at retail (out of stock). - Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 3Evidence: Low
$19.99 Secondary
Read a retail listing (Sheet Music Plus) in the initial research, but the 2026-11-21 re-check could not retrieve either the retail or the publisher's (Kjos) page, so it is unconfirmed. Amazon shows yen prices that cannot be compared. Some information gives $17.99–$34.99 depending on the store, but the upper figure does not match Book 2's range and needs re-verification - Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) 5Evidence: High
Free ($0) Official
Free on IMSLP. A printed edition costs extra - Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 3Evidence: High
$19.99 Official
Re-checked on the official store product page (2026-11-21; print edition $19.99). Includes audio and video. The official app is optional (unlocking all songs costs $4.99 per level; how Adult Book 1 is handled is unclear). - Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 2Evidence: High
$19.99 Official
The official page shows "Price: $19.99 (US)" (re-checked 2026-11-21). Includes online audio. Availability problems (back order; not purchasable in some countries) - SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) 5Evidence: Medium
Free ($0) Official
The PDF is free with no registration (confirmed 2026-11-21). Ongoing app learning is $2.90 per month. The app's judging requires a USB MIDI keyboard
C12 Track record
Years since first publication; edition and revision history; number of independent user voices
- Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 4Evidence: Low
CD edition: July 1994 (Open Library only). DVD edition: June 1, 2011 (Amazon.com) Catalog
1994 comes from the library catalog only. Not confirmed at a retail site (the Amazon page could not be retrieved) - Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 3Evidence: Medium
January 1, 1999 (Amazon.com). The library catalog also says 1999 Retail
Unclear whether the current online edition is the same edition as in 1999 - Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) 5Evidence: Medium
1850, Mainz: Schott Official
The introduction to Japan (1881) is quoted from Japanese Wikipedia (weakly sourced) - Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 5Evidence: Medium
2002, 2016 (the publication-date field in the product information) Official
Whether 2002 is the first-edition year is an inference - Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 5Evidence: Medium
February 28, 2005 (Amazon.com; the ISBN's registration date). The older edition with a CD is August 24, 2006 Retail
No year is stated on the official page. The library catalog says March 2005 (Open Library). The ISBN's date is not necessarily the first publication date - SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) 1Evidence: High
November 2026, first edition (PDF created 2026-11-18) Original
Verification levels
- Official Official (publisher, developer, IMSLP, etc.). Note that a developer's own site is self-reported
- Original Original (the material itself; the table of contents, text, or PDF was read directly)
- Retail What a retail site or store displays (editions and figures may be inconsistent)
- Catalog Library catalogs and bibliographic databases
- Teacher Reviews by teachers and experts
- User Reviews by purchasers and users
- Research Research papers (those whose full text was read)
- Secondary Secondary information (search-result summaries, second-hand quotations, etc.)
- Inference The author's inference (not fact)
- Unconfirmed Could not be confirmed (this does not mean "absent")