Criteria & averages
The 12 criteria
I found no study comparing materials for adult beginners. The criteria organize the factors suggested in the literature and common points in pedagogy into features that can be checked in a material.
C1 A quick "this is music" experience
Pages before the first piece; what the first piece is
| 5 pts | Within the first few pages there is an experience of enjoying real music, for example with accompaniment |
|---|---|
| 3 pts | A music-like experience comes partway through the opening |
| 1 pts | The opening is only exercises and has little feel of music |
C2 Pieces you like and know
Kinds of pieces, and the share of well-known ones
| 5 pts | Many well-known pieces across a wide range of genres (including pop and jazz) |
|---|---|
| 3 pts | Some well-known pieces, but the genres are limited or opinions are split |
| 2 pts | Well-known pieces are under 30% of the total and the genres are limited |
| 1 pts | No titles, and almost no well-known pieces |
C3 Suitable pace
How quickly new elements arrive; amount of review
| 5 pts | New elements arrive gradually, with review, and there are no reports of sudden jumps in difficulty |
|---|---|
| 3 pts | Leans toward too fast or too slow, or there are reports of jumps |
| 1 pts | Extremely slow or extremely fast |
C4 Gradual, explicit introduction of note reading
Starting position, the page where the staff appears, new notes per page
| 5 pts | New elements are introduced one at a time with explanation and reinforced by reappearing |
|---|---|
| 3 pts | There is a progression, but explanations or reappearance are limited |
| 1 pts | The progression is unclear, or there are no explanations |
C5 Support for how to practice (within the book)
Practice tips, unit goals, review, self-checks
| 5 pts | The practice procedure is written concretely in the text |
|---|---|
| 3 pts | There is review and checking, but few instructions on how to practice |
| 1 pts | No description |
C6 Support for self-study (audio, video, explanations)
Accompaniment audio, video, speed control, amount of explanation
| 5 pts | Detailed explanations, and audio and video let you check things without a teacher |
|---|---|
| 3 pts | Some support, but a teacher is needed in many respects |
| 1 pts | No explanations or audio; a teacher is assumed |
C7 Consideration for limited time
Length of a unit; how it is chunked
| 5 pts | Can be done in small units, so you can progress even in a short time |
|---|---|
| 3 pts | Standard |
| 1 pts | Very long; each stopping point is heavy |
C8 Practical skills (chords, theory, ear, improvisation, transposition)
Whether the relevant pages exist
| 5 pts | Several areas are included in the text |
|---|---|
| 3 pts | Theory is included, but the others are limited |
| 1 pts | Almost none included |
C9 Body and technique (posture, hand shape, relaxation)
Instruction on posture and hand shape; technique exercises
| 5 pts | Posture, hand shape, and relaxation are explained in the text |
|---|---|
| 3 pts | Technique exercises exist, but explanation of posture and so on is limited |
| 1 pts | No description |
C10 Adult-oriented look and tone
Layout, type size, tone
| 5 pts | An adult-oriented look, with several sources agreeing |
|---|---|
| 3 pts | Opinions are split, or it has no distinguishing feature |
| 1 pts | A material intended for children |
C11 Purchase cost
Spending needed to work through Book 1 using the audio too (US list price)(Purchase cost. Not included in the main average)
| 5 pts | Free, and the whole volume can be used |
|---|---|
| 4 pts | Under $20, with audio included and no extra purchase or purchasing limits |
| 3 pts | About $20, with audio included and no extra purchase or purchasing limits |
| 2 pts | About $20 with other limits (an extra purchase is needed, purchase or availability is restricted, etc.), or roughly $20–$45 |
| 1 pts | Over $45, or a required monthly fee that continues for a long time |
C12 Track record
Years since first publication; edition and revision history; number of independent user voices
| 5 pts | 20+ years since first publication, editions continue, and several independent user voices |
|---|---|
| 4 pts | 10+ years, and user voices can be confirmed |
| 3 pts | 5–10 years, or a long history but no user voices can be confirmed |
| 2 pts | Under 5 years, and a few user voices can be confirmed |
| 1 pts | Under 1 year since publication, or no independent user voices |
Averages
Averages are reference values, not a ranking. Some items could not be scored (the number in parentheses is the number of scored items), and many scores have low evidence strength, so you cannot say there are differences. Too few items could be scored for Bastien, so it cannot be used for comparison. Which criteria matter differs from person to person, so please look directly at the scores for the criteria you care about.
| Alfred Adult All-in-One Book 1 | Bastien Piano for Adults Book 1 | Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain) | Faber Adult Piano Adventures Book 1 | Hal Leonard Adult Piano Method Book 1 | SightBasics Part 1: First Steps at the Piano (PDF) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1–C10 (without track record) | 3.3(10 items) | 3.0(5 items) | 1.5(8 items) | 3.6(10 items) | 3.8(9 items) | 3.8(10 items) |
| C1–C10 + C12 (with track record) | 3.4(11 items) | 3.0(6 items) | 1.9(9 items) | 3.7(11 items) | 3.9(10 items) | 3.5(11 items) |
| All C1–C12 (including purchase cost) | 3.3(12 items) | 3.0(7 items) | 2.2(10 items) | 3.7(12 items) | 3.7(11 items) | 3.7(12 items) |
- The track record (C12) is unfavorable to new materials. Having been in print for a long time is not proof of quality.
- Purchase cost (C11) is a budget constraint, not the quality of the material. It is not included in the main average because it makes free materials look high.
- The criteria were written out and adjusted after examining the materials.