Beyer: Vorschule im Klavierspiel, Op. 101 (public domain)
Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 / Back to the comparison table
Official page: IMSLP (public score library) (It is public domain, so there is no official publisher page. Display confirmed 2026-11-21)
Mainly IMSLP bibliographic information and reviews in Japanese and English. The score itself was not read.
Checked: 2026-11-21. Facts (18) come first, followed by the author's judgment (scores).
Basic information / Facts by criterion (C1–C10) / Purchase cost and track record (C11, C12) / IT and digital support / Scores and reasons / Reputation
Basic information
| Item | Content | Verified | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Authors / editors | Ferdinand Beyer. The editor differs by edition | Official 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
| Pages | 77–93 (varies by scanned edition) | Official 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
| Contents | Studies only. 106 pieces in 2 stages | Official 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
| Original title and dedication | "For pupils of the most tender age"; dedicated "to the mothers" | Official 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
| Copyright status | A mix of scans marked public domain and scans marked "Public Domain – Non-PD EU" (Piccioli/Curci, Pozzoli/Ricordi) Check each edition's license notice before redistributing | Official 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
Facts by criterion (C1–C10)
| Item | Content | Verified | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| C1 First piece | Studies only. No titles, accompaniment, or audio. Details such as the range and content of the first piece are unconfirmed "Studies only" is IMSLP's description. The score itself was not read | Official 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
| C2 Kinds of pieces | No titles, only numbers. "The pieces are monotonous" (grade A) | Official 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
| C3 Pace | Extremely slow. Little changes from piece to piece The actual structure is unconfirmed | Inference 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
| C4 Note-reading approach | Starts from the basics of the staff (details unconfirmed) The IMSLP scans could not be read | Unconfirmed 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
| C5 Practice support | No instructions in the text could be confirmed (it is not asserted that there are none) | Unconfirmed 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
| C6 Self-study | No explanations, audio, or video. One performance recording on IMSLP (No. 62, CC BY-SA 4.0) | Official 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
| C7 Time constraints | The pieces are short, and you can work on one at a time | Inference 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
| C8 Practical skills | No description of chords or theory | Inference 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
| C9 Body and technique | A user's specific remark that explanations of pedal and positions are missing. Unconfirmed in the original An article on note (a Japanese blog platform). The source URL was not recorded. A search summary of Piano World says much the same | User 2026-11-21 | Source URL not recorded (to be re-verified) |
| C10 Look and tone | Made for children (original title and dedication) | Official 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
Purchase cost and track record (C11, C12)
| Item | Content | Verified | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| US list price (USD) | Free ($0) Free on IMSLP. A printed edition costs extra | Official 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
| Year of publication | 1850, Mainz: Schott The introduction to Japan (1881) is quoted from Japanese Wikipedia (weakly sourced) | Official 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
IT and digital support
| Item | Content | Verified | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Digital features | None. Download the PDF. No audio, MIDI, or MusicXML was found | Official 2026-11-21 | IMSLP: Beyer Vorschule im Klavierspiel Op.101 |
Scores and reasons (the author's judgment)
Scores are the author's judgment based on the facts above. "Evidence" is the strength of the information supporting the score.
| Criterion | Score | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| C1 A quick "this is music" experience | 2Evidence: Low | Studies only, with no titles or accompaniment (IMSLP). Details of the first piece are unconfirmed |
| C2 Pieces you like and know | 1Evidence: Medium | No titles, and "the pieces are monotonous" (grade A) |
| C3 Suitable pace | 2Evidence: Medium | Extremely slow and long at 106 pieces (grade A: gradual but monotonous) |
| C4 Gradual, explicit introduction of note reading | Not scored | "Gradual" (grade A), but the structure was not confirmed from the score itself, so it is not scored |
| C5 Support for how to practice (within the book) | Not scored | No instructions in the text could be confirmed. Not scored, because "not confirmed" is not evidence of "absent" (the earlier version gave 1 point) |
| C6 Support for self-study (audio, video, explanations) | 1Evidence: High | No explanations, audio, or video (grade A) |
| C7 Consideration for limited time | 3Evidence: Low | The pieces are short and you can work on one at a time (inferred) |
| C8 Practical skills (chords, theory, ear, improvisation, transposition) | 1Evidence: Medium | No description of chords or theory (grade A: too little explanation) |
| C9 Body and technique (posture, hand shape, relaxation) | 1Evidence: Low | A user's remark that explanations of pedal and positions are missing (note). Unconfirmed in the original |
| C10 Adult-oriented look and tone | 1Evidence: Medium | The original title is "for pupils of the most tender age" and the dedication is "to the mothers". Made for children |
| C11 Purchase cost | 5Evidence: High | Free on IMSLP. No audio or explanations (already evaluated under C6 and C8) |
| C12 Track record | 5Evidence: Medium | 1850 (IMSLP), many editions. 3 confirmations from actual users |
What reviews agree on (reputation)
Grades: A = three or more independent sources agree, they include people who actually used it, and there is no opposing opinion. B = agreement, but weak. C = individual opinions, or split. The reviews skew toward affiliate articles (see Limits).
| Point | Grade | Sources behind it |
|---|---|---|
| Monotonous pieces that are easy to tire of | A | note (Japanese blog platform), ピアノサプリ (Japanese site), Italian Piano, Piano World (search summary), Amazon.co.jp (search summary) Includes secondary information |
| Lacks explanation on its own; needs supplementary materials or a teacher | A | note (Japanese blog platform), Piano Lessons, Italian Piano, コエテコ (Japanese site), Piano World (search summary) |
| Progresses gradually | A | まいたけな日々 (Japanese blog; finished all 106 pieces), Piano Lessons, コエテコ (Japanese site), Italian Piano (a seller) A seller's opinion is discounted |